|
Words Of Wisdom by Prof B. M. Hegde
East Is Meeting West
Narendranath
Dutta ( 1862-1902), a Calcutta intellectual of great
repute, popularly known as Swami Vivekananda, prophesied
one hundred years ago in 1897, "the problems of life
are becoming deeper and broader every day as the world
moves on. One atom in this Universe cannot move without
dragging the whole world along with it. There cannot be
any progress without the whole world following in its
wake and it is becoming clearer everyday that the
solution of any problem can never be attained on racial,
national, or narrow grounds. Every idea has to be broad
till it covers the whole world...."
This prophecy has come true today. Despite all our
advances in the technological and scientific fields, man
still remains the same. It looks as if he is going to
destroy all the natural resources of this earth because
of his proclivity for comfort and his greed. Although man
has been successful in landing on the moon, he finds it
difficult to land happily in his own neighbours
house with a smile.
The old concept of the East, of "Vasudaiva
Kutumbikam" (the whole world is one big family) has
to be revived for the good of humanity. We were but one
large family even according to the scientific findings.
This world was once one land mass which broke up over
millions of years, with the sea coming in between, into
the present day continents. Studies have shown that the
sense of belonging, in the large family system in the old
sustenance economies, was responsible for the lower
incidence of degenerative and psychosomatic diseases in
the past.
The languages of the world give an inkling into this. The
Indo-European languages of today were, thousands of years
ago, a single language. The words of any language are
like the cells of an organism. They change, mutate, and
migrate, like the speciation observed by Darwin on the
islands of the Galapagos.
If one goes back to the fossil roots of some words this
could easily be understood, that we have all come from
the same human family.
| Sanskrit |
Latin |
Medieval
French |
German |
Modern
English |
| Brahman |
Flamen |
Flamen |
|
Flame |
| Veda |
Videre |
Wis (dom) |
Witen |
Vision |
| Bodathi |
Beudh |
Beodan |
|
|
| Mathr |
Mater |
Mere |
|
Mother |
| Pithr |
Pater |
Pere |
|
Father |
Man is a
social animal. We do not behave like social animals under
all circumstances. It has been said that the only thing
that is innate in us is our language. If that were so,
music and language are the two human activities, which
will never die out, but might keep us together despite
all our efforts to destroy ourselves, with our new
technologies. While so much progress has been made in
physics, very little has happend in the field of social
sciences. Einstein was said to have remarked that "
physics is much simpler than social science."
Unlike many animals, we are not genetically programmed to
live and work together for our common good. We behave
differently at different times and do not think with our
minds together. A look at the ants( or termites), which
are almost blind and have hardly any brain tissue, and
the way they behave in groups, should amaze any thinking
man or woman and put them to shame. Ants build such
fantastic homes (ant hills); some of which spread over
hundreds of meters with hillocks. They have excellent
air-conditioning and have special chambers to grow fungi
for their food. They have special room on the top for
their queen. The whole edifice is based on a simple arch.
Even our best engineers and architects should marvel at
their ingenuity. Gassi showed in elegant experiments how
ants, left in isolation, are almost blind. When they are
together they try to build the arch in such complicated
ways that it is only possible with a collective Consciousness.
This is genetically programmed.
If only men and women could come together with their
large brains and their collective consciousness , we
could do wonders for mankind. The evolution of the human
species resulted in the large brain which in turn
favoured the adaptive success of an advanced form. The
beauty of all this could be enjoyed in the book Man
Makes Himself by a leading archeologist, Gordon
Childe. This idea of the individual vis-à-vis a
collective Universal Consciousness was well
developed in the Sanatana Dharma of the East. Today we
have to learn it from the ants and termites! Knowledge
and wisdom do not belong to any particular age, race,
religion or nation. They are ever present, ever changing,
evolving thought processes emanating from individuals and
groups. Let us look at a few of these milestones.
We talk of scientific fantasy and the realities today.
Consider some of the great Eastern epics like the
Mahabharata and the Ramayana. We now have airplanes,
missiles, tele-communications, people landing on the moon
and mars. We may take these things in our stride, but
these realities of today existed as fantasies to our
fore-fathers thousands of years ago. The epics might have
been novels of their` time; even if we do not accept them
as gospels of those days, but they were talking about
potential realities of the time, with graphic details of
the intricacies of human behaviour. They are a source of
eternal peace and tranquillity.
Most of the hi-tech stuff of the present day are only
half way technologies. This is very much true in the
field of medicine, nay in all the sciences. What is science?
Is an excellent question and the best answer is
" science is what scientists do", put
differently in Dutch it sounds better- Wetenschap
Is Wat Wetenschappers Doen. Let us look at some
of these. Lewis Thomas, former President of the
Sloan-Kettering Cancer Centre in New York, in his book
The Lives of a Cell classifies modern-technology in
medicine into three groups".(1)
- Non-Technology:-
The so-called supportive therapy.
- Half-way
Technology:- Technology designed to palliate
( to cloak ) symptoms and postpone death if
possible! Outstanding examples being spare-part
surgery, artificial organs, coronary bypass
surgeries, angioplasties, cancer therapy etc.
They are, in addition, prohibitively expensive
from the community point of view. Even today
approximately 80% of the world population depends
wholly or partially on traditional medicines for
primary health care.
- Really hi-tech: That
which comes with good understanding of the
disease process. This class is "highly
sophisticated and profoundly primitive". It
attracts least public notice. Lewis Thomas puts
smallpox eradication by vaccination in this
category.
Credit here must surely go
to Edward Jenner but the real hero was that thirteen year
old innocent boy, James Phipps, who did not know that he
was being used as a guinea pig in a possibly fatal
experiment, when Edward Jenner gave him an inoculation of
live small pox virus. This was based on anecdotal
information from a milk maid, Norma, that people who get
cowpox (in latin vacca means cow) do not suffer
from small pox. Edward Jenner did something which
todays science and medical ethics would not have
forgiven. Since the experiment succeeded, we applaud
Jenner. If the experiment had failed the world would not
have known that an innocent boy was killed by research
misadventure! God only knows how many innocent lives have
been lost in such heroic experiments where the
former were used unbeknownst to them. Few in the West
know that we in India had an elaborate system of small
pox vaccination, the details of which were documented by
Dr. J.H. Holwell, F.R.S. in his letter to the President
of the Royal College of Physicians of London in the year
1747 AD. (2)
"On pursuing lately some tracts upon the subject of
Inoculation, I determined to put together a few notes
relative to the manner of Inoculation, practised, time
out of mind by the Brahmins of Indostan; to this I was
chiefly investigated, by the great benefit that may arise
to mankind from a knowledge of this foreign method, which
so remarkably tends to support the practice now generally
followed with such marvelous success".
The story of smallpox goes thus: "By the earliest
account we have of small pox, we find it first appeared
in Egypt in the time of Omar, successor to Mahomet;
though no doubt, since the Greeks knew nothing of it, the
Arabians brought it from their own country; but might
derive it originally from some of the more distant
regions of the East".
The sagacity of the above conclusions, later times and
discoveries has fully verified, three thousand three
hundred years before 1747 AD (five thousand years ago) as
the Indian scriptures institute a form of divine worship
(Poojah) to the "Goddess of the spots".
Inoculation is performed in Indostan by a particular
tribe of Brahmins, who are delegated annually for this
service from the different Colleges of Bindoobund,
Eleabas, Banaras, &c. Over all the distant provinces;
dividing themselves into small parties, of three or four
each, they plan their traveling circuits in such ways as
to arrive at the places of their respective destination
some weeks before the usual return of the disease; they
arrive commonly in the Bengall provinces early in
February, although they some years do not begin to
inoculate before March, deferring it until they consider
the state of the season, and acquire information of the
state of the distemper.
The inhabitants of Bengall, knowing the usual time when
the inoculating Brahmins annually return, observe
strictly the regimen enjoined, whether they determine to
be inoculated or not; this preparation consists only in
abstaining for a month from fish, milk, and ghee, (a kind
of butter made generally of buffalos milk ); the
prohibition of fish respects only the native Portuguese
and Mohammedans, who abound in every province of the
empire.
When the Brahmins begin to inoculate, they pass from
house to house and operate at the door, refusing to
inoculate any who have not, on a strict scrutiny, duly
observed the preparatory course enjoined them. It is no
uncommon thing for them to ask the parents how many pocks
they chuse their question on a matter seemingly so
uncertain in the issue; but true it is, that they hardly
ever exceed, or are deficient, in the number required.
Previous to the operation the Operator takes a piece of
cloth in his hand, (which becomes his perquisite if the
family is opulent,) and with it gives a dry friction upon
the part intended for inoculation, for the space of eight
or ten minutes, then with a small instrument he wounds,
by many slight touches, about the compass of a silver
groat, just making the smallest appearance of blood, then
opening a linen double rag (which he always keeps in a
cloth round his waist) takes from thence a small pledgit
of cotton charged with the variolous matter, which he
moistens with two or three drops of the Ganges Water, and
applies it to the wound, fixing it on with a slight
bandage, and ordering it to remain on for six hours
without being moved, then the bandage to be taken off,
and the pledget to remain until it falls off itself;
sometimes (but rarely) he squeezes a drop from the
pledget, upon the part, before he applies it; from the
time he begins the dry friction, to tying the knot of the
bandage, he never ceases reciting some portions of the
worship appointed, by the Aughtorrah Bhade, to be paid to
the female divinity before-mentioned, nor quits the most
solemn countenance all the while. The cotton, which he
preserves in a double callico rag, is saturated with
matter from the inoculated pustules of the preceding
year, for they never inoculate with fresh matter, nor
with matter from the disease caught in the natural way,
however distinct and mild the species. He then proceeds
to give instructions for the treatment of the patient
through the course of the process, which are most
religiously observed.
The instrument they make use of, is of iron, about four
inches and a half long, and of the size of a large crow
quill, the middle is twisted, and the one end is steeled
and flatted about an inch from the extremity, and the
eighth of an inch broad; this extremity is brought to a
very keen edge, and two sharp corners; the other end of
the instrument is an earpicker, and the instrument is
precisely the same as the Barbers of Indostan use to cut
the nails, and depurate the ears of their customers, (for
in that country, we are above performing either of these
operations ourselves.) The Operator of inoculation holds
the instrument as we hold a pen, and with dexterous
expedition gives about fifteen or sixteen minute
scarifications (within the compass above mentioned) with
one of the sharp corners of the instrument, and to these
various little wounds, I believe may be ascribed the
discharge which almost constantly flows from the part in
the progress of the disease. I cannot help thinking that
too much has been said (pro and con) about nothing,
respecting the different methods preferred by different
practitioners of performing the operation; provided the
matter is thrown into the blood, it is certainly, a
consideration of most trivial import by what means it is
effected; if any claims a preference, I should conclude
it should be that method which bids fairest for securing
a plentiful discharge from the ulcer.
Pain:
Even in other fields of medicine there have been major
East-West co-operation efforts that do not come to the
knowledge of the present day doctor Charakas
writings and Hippocratic writings have many things in
common. Prof. Kutumbiah of the Madras University in his
book The History of Medicine has the following
explanation for the above. The theory of the three basic
faults in the system according to Ayurveda, the
Tridoshas, is identical to the humors theory of
Hippocrates.
Alexander the Great invaded India and took back Indian
books and scholars with him around 400 BC. Even though
Alexander did not reach Greece, the books and scholars
did go to Alexandria. Hippocratic writings are around 100
BC and were possibly influenced by the old Indian
Scriptures.
The following stanza in the Shushrutha Samhita,
the most important text book in Ayurveda, clearly
describes the pain of myocardial ischaemia (anginal pain)
in such great detail that it cannot be bettered even now.
The interesting aspect of the whole thing is the
reference to the cause of pain in the beginning of the
stanza, viz.: "hradrogam" (heart disease).
Heberden, an English physician, credited with the first
authentic documentation of angina pectoris in the 18th
century gave a graphic description of his own chest pain,
but had no idea that the pain came from the heart. His
student, Edward Jenner, of vaccination fame, thought that
his bosss chest pain was due to syphilis. It was
only around 1905 that William Osler, a great medical
brain of this century, postulated that the chest pain
that Heberden had could have been due to heart disease.
Although once called the English disease, angina has its
first well documented authentic description in Ayurveda.
Thrichatwarimshathammodhyayah:
"
Athaatho Hradrogaprathishedam Vyakyaswamyah
Yathovaacha Bhaghavan Dhanvantharim (suthruthaya)".
Aayammyathe
Maaruthaje Hradayam Thudyathe,
Nirmathyathe Dheeryathe Cha Spotyathe Paaticha,
Thrishnoshadaahachoshaam Syuhu Paithikecha,
Dhoomaayanam Cha Moorchaa Cha Swedhahako.
[In this chapter Bhgavan
Dhanvanthari, the God of healing, personally describes
the symptoms of heart disease and impending death
due to heart attacks. Patient may feel pricking pain,
vibrations ( palpitations), burning pain, at times the
pain may be very severe resembling the pain of splitting
the chest into two halves with an axe! He may have
unusual thirst, burning all over, breathlessness, extreme
exhaustion, mouth breathing because he can not have
enough breath through his nostrils, profuse sweating,
pale face, stiffness of the body parts, and, finally,
even unconsciousness may result! ] (3)
The role of the human mind in disease is a recent thought
in modern medicine. The earliest document in this field
is that of William Harvey (AD 1648) which goes thus:
" I was acquainted with another strong man, who
having received an injury and affront from one more
powerful than himself, and upon whom he could not have
his revenge, was so overcome with hatred and spite and
passion, which he yet communicated to no one, that at
last he fell into a strange distemper, suffering from
extreme oppression and pain of the heart and breast and
in the course of a few years died. His friends thought
him poisoned by some maleficent influence, or possessed
with an evil spirit ..... In the dead body I found the
heart and aorta so much gorged and distended with blood,
that the cavities of the ventricles equaled those of a
bullocks heart in size. Such is the force of the
blood pent up, and such are the effects of its
impulse..... We also observe the signal influence of the
affections of the mind when a timid person is arrested, a
deadly pallor overspreads the surface, the limbs stiffen,
the ears sing, the eyes are dazzled or blinded, and, as
it were, convulsed. But here I come upon a field where I
might roam freely and give myself up to speculation. And,
indeed, such a flood of light and truth breaks in upon me
here; occasion offers of explaining so many problems, of
resolving so many doubts, of discovering the causes of so
many problems, so many slighter and more serious
diseases, and of suggesting remedies for their cure, that
the subject seems almost to demand a separate treatise...
... And what indeed is more deserving of attention than
the fact that in almost every affection, appetite, hope
or fear, our body suffers, the countenance changes, and
the blood appears to course hither and thither. In anger
the eyes are fiery and pupils contracted; in modesty the
cheeks are suffused with blushes; in fear, and under a
sense of infamy and of shame, the face is pale, but the
ears burn as if for the evil they heard or were to hear;
in lust how quickly is the member distended with blood
and erected ! "(4) .
It is only an year ago that a large study in the USA
reported "anger" as the most important risk
factor for strokes. A glance at the following stanza will
convince one about the ancient eastern thinking in this
field.
"Khrodha
Shoka Bhaya Aayaasa VirudhannaBhojana Thaponnalan,
Katwaamla Lavana Theekshnonathi Raktha Pitta
Prakopayeth"
[ Anger, sorrow, fear,
exhaustion, wrong type of food, sedentary living, acidic
diet, salt, too much of condiments in diet will
eventually lead on to all the disturbances in every
system of the body.]
Death:
Death, the most dreaded aspect of human existence
today, and the only certainty in life, is the cause of
much of the anxieties in life. Anxiety is the sole basis
of modern medical practice. It is either patient anxiety
of death and disability or the doctor anxiety of having
not done enough for his patient. If one could find an
answer for this foundation of human misery, he would
certainly be picked up by the Swedish Academy for a Nobel
prize. Death is feared by most because their perception
of death, the end in itself, could be horrible. There are
references to the horrors of death in the literature. The
fact still remains that death, as reported by those who
experienced near death situations, seems to be a very
pleasant and tranquil affair. David Johnson, who was
crushed by a lion in Africa, only to be saved at the last
minute by a friends bullet, describes it as a very
pleasant experience.(1) Raymond Moody Jrs
account of his patients after a heart attack and cardiac
standstill also looks pleasant.
Be that as it may, the eastern philosophy of life after
death or the immortality of the soul, athman,(
anima ) gives lot of solace to the bereaved family. Death
is inevitable, and has very little to do with diseases.
It is connected to diseases by the present day market
forces, ( getting into medicine in a big way ) to make
money out of human misery. Even if all our cancers,
coronaries, and strokes were to disappear ( wishful
thinking ) we would still have people dying of old age.
Even if death could be postponed, this idea is being sold
everyday in the "hi-tech" medical world, the
borrowed life would not be normal. It is impossible to
prevent or reverse ageing with present day knowledge.
This was known to our forefathers who propounded the
highest wisdom of the individual consciousness that
merges with the Universal consciousness to become
immortal.
Let us take another field of our present day knowledge.
The heart is described as a muscular pump. Frank
Starling, in the year 1917, delivering the Lumlein
lecture at the Royal College of Physicians of London,
thought that the working of the heart is so complicated
that he thought only God could comprehend its action in
toto. He said that he would confine himself only to its
pumping function for the time being. However, the idea
that the heart is only a pump persisted for a very long
time up until the present times. It was only three years
ago that the International Phlebology Congress had a
presentation of data in the cine film showing the sucking
function of the heart of columns of venous blood with
each diastole of the atria. If you went back five
thousand years in history there are references to the
latter diastolic function of the heart in Ayurveda. In
fact, the very name `heart denotes that. ( Hridaya=
heart ; Hri=suck and Da= give or pump.)
Teleology ( Why? ) is beyond biology ( How? ). However,
the eastern and western wisdom combined together may be
able to give solace to the troubled mind, which seems to
be at the root of most, if not all, problems of mankind.
The farthest that the West has gone in this field is what
Rene Descartes wrote " There is a great difference
between the mind and body, in that the body by its nature
is divisible and that mind is entirely indivisible- this
teaches me that the mind or soul is entirely different
from the body." This brought all the problems for
the West. Up until that time westerners followed Pascal.
The Cartesian logic culminated in the present
reductionist science, which has reached a point of no
return. Science was heading for a crisis of
specialisation when, in the distant horizon, appeared the
new science of CHAOS, which seemed to have cleared the
mist in the area. Chaos has many things in common with
the age old wisdom of the East. Both of them look at the
world as a whole. This holistic view is depicted in the
following stanza from the Upanishads.
"
Poornam Idaha, Poornam Adaha..........Poornasya Poornam
Aaadaaya, Poornam Evashistathe."
[ This is a whole, That is
a whole....If you take a bit from the whole, the bit
becomes a whole and the whole remains a whole.]
Descartes was only
seventeen when he wrote that piece mentioned above. In
his later years wisdom must have dawned on him. He used
to advise his friends about matters of health from time
to time. He once wrote to one of his Royal acquaintances
that her bodily symptoms were the outer expression of the
inner anguish in her mind, contradicting his own original
hypothesis of "Cogito ergo sum". Unfortunately,
the latter aspect of Descartes thinking did not
find as much publicity as did the earlier one. One of the
great Nobel laureate physicists, Werner Hisenberg, meant
the same when he propounded the Uncertainty Principle,
based on his Gadenkenexperiments on the Hines mountains,
almost identical to the eastern rishis(saints).
Western science postulates that Consciousness is a
fundamental component of the Universe like mass and
gravity. " The brain requires a new theory linking
events at the quantum level with those of the macroscopic
world" wrote Stuart A.E, a Scotish pathologist, in
1997(5). We are drawing closer these days. Even in
the sphere of science the East meets the West. The
distance is truly dying, if not dead already! Even in the
physical field the distance is dead and the world has
become a global village, thanks to the jet aircraft,
telephones, television, faxes, and the E-mail.
Let us look for the strongest glue to bring man and man
together and keep it that way for the good of the future
generations. The missing " gluon" seems to be Human
Love, which should be identical in the East and the
West. Long Live mankind!.
|